Burger & Shake Restaurant near Murray Hill, New York City

There are few things in life that go together quite as perfectly as a juicy burger and a cold, creamy milkshake. On their own, each one is a rockstar in the world of American cuisine. A well-built burger is a handheld masterpiece layered with savory beef, fresh toppings, melty cheese, and a perfectly-toasted bun that holds it all together. Milkshakes are sweet, smooth, and nostalgic, swirling immense flavor and reassuring comfort into a single glass. When you put them together, magic happens. The richness of the meat balanced by the cool sweetness of the shake creates a duo that’s been enjoyed across generations, across the country, and especially throughout NYC.

That is why Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer is thrilled to be recognized as a top burger & shake restaurant near Murray Hill, New York City. Our beloved menu is built around bold flavors, fresh ingredients, and top-tier creativity, all served up in a welcoming space with serious style. We’re certain to have what you desire, whether you’re a burger purist, a milkshake enthusiast, or someone who truly loves both. From gourmet craft burgers to outrageously-delicious CrazyShakes®, our offerings hit hard in all the right ways. Add to that an atmosphere filled with good vibes, custom murals, and an iconic NYC backdrop, and you’ve got yourself a spot worth returning to again and again.

Burger and Shake Restaurants Near Me

Our burger game is the strongest there is. When you walk into Black Tap, you’re not just ordering a hamburger. You’re getting a next-level creation stacked with thoughtful ingredients, punchy flavor combos, and just the perfect amount of indulgence. Every burger comes with lettuce, tomato, a crisp pickle, and a side of French fries, but the real fun is in the details. We keep things classic when it counts, and creative where it matters.

The All-American Burger at our Murray Hill, NYC hamburger and milkshake restaurant is a loving tribute to simplicity done right. A prime beef patty, American cheese, and our signature special sauce make this cheeseburger a go-to for those who know what they like. If you’re in the mood for something with a smoky, southern kick, the Texan Burger brings aged cheddar cheese, crispy bacon, a golden onion ring, Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ sauce, and creamy mayo together for a flavor-filled ride.

For the spice lovers out there, the Mexico City burger turns up the heat with pepper jack cheese, pickled jalapeños, and chipotle mayo, all tied together with a crispy onion ring on top. The Old Fashioned is your pick if you’re after something rich and savory to enjoy. It comes loaded with Swiss cheese, cremini mushrooms, caramelized onions, and horseradish sauce, giving you layer upon layer of deep, umami flavor.

Gourmet Wagyu Burgers

Meat lovers with a taste for the finer things will appreciate the award-winning wagyu burger options at our hamburger & shake spot near Murray Hill, New York City. The Champ boasts a half-pound wagyu patty topped with blue cheese, arugula, and our house buttermilk-dill for a sophisticated bite that is hearty and fresh at the same time. The Wagyu Steakhouse Burger takes things up a notch with pepper jack cheese, crispy onions, roasted garlic mayo, and a bold splash of A1 sauce. Add bacon to it, and you’re in cheeseburger heaven.

If you’re feeling particularly adventurous, we encourage you to check out the Mulberry Street Burger. This one is a love letter to Italian-American cuisine, featuring prosciutto, soppressata, provolone, hot cherry peppers, roasted garlic aioli, and shaved parmesan. It’s a savory, spicy, and immensely satisfying bite that makes a strong statement. And for those looking for something a little lighter or non-traditional, we’ve got you covered with options like the Black Bean Burger or the California Turkey Burger. Our menu brings true diversity to the burger scene, including vegan and gluten-free buns to make sure no one is left out of the experience.

Murray Hill, NYC Hamburger & Shake Spot

Pairing a burger with a milkshake isn’t just a good idea. It’s the right idea. And here at our Murray Hill cheeseburger and shake place, the shake selection is stacked with options that deliver major flavor and flair. Our Classic Shakes feature beloved standards like Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry, and even Oreo Cookies & Cream. These shakes are thick and creamy, making them the perfect counterpart to a juicy beef burger and salted French fries.

If you’re here for a real showstopper, our CrazyShakes® are the move. These are far more than just your usual milkshakes. Rather, they’re full-on dessert experiences topped with everything from cheesecake slices to entire brownies. The New Yorker shake features a strawberry base and is crowned with an actual slice of strawberry cheesecake, while the CakeShake® is a wonderful birthday celebration in a glass, topped with a slice of funfetti cake and rainbow sprinkles. If chocolate is more your thing, the Brooklyn Blackout shake is an all-star with brownies, chocolate chips, and fudge drizzle on top of a chocolate shake with a chocolate-frosted rim.

Craving something cookie-packed instead? The Cookies ‘n Cream Supreme is an Oreo lover’s dream, and the Cookie Shake brings a vanilla cookie base topped with a cookie sandwich, cookie crumbles, and a drizzle of chocolate. For something especially whimsical, the Cotton Candy Shake comes dressed in pink and blue sprinkles with a lollipop and cotton candy fluff. They’re fun, over-the-top, and undeniably Black Tap.

Just remember that these CrazyShakes® are only available for dine-in. If you’re ordering for pickup or local delivery, you’ll want to stick to the Classic Shakes. They travel best and still bring that perfect milkshake magic to go.

Dine-in, Pickup & Delivery Available for Our Cheeseburgers and Shakes

When you make your way into this Black Tap flagship location, you’re stepping into a space that celebrates flavor, culture, and creativity. Designed by the award-winning Rockwell Group, this burger and milkshake spot near Murray Hill, Manhattan amps up the vibes from our original SoHo spot with bold artwork, a full bar, and design features that are unmistakably New York. From the custom mural installations to the wall lined with 4,000 cassette tapes, every detail is meant to enhance your overall experience.

We also feature the very first standalone CrazyShake® Bar in the city, offering a dedicated space to indulge your sweet tooth and snap that perfect shake pic. Whether you’re sitting down for a relaxing meal with friends, celebrating something special, or just in the mood to treat yourself, we’ve built the kind of burger & shake spot near Murray Hill, NYC that makes memories as well as meals.

If you’d prefer to enjoy your burger and shake at home, we’ve made that just as easy. You can place a pickup or delivery order online through the website. Choose your craft burger, select your sides, add a Classic Shake, and you’re set. Feel free to customize your order, from bun type to toppings, and we’ll handle the rest. You can also give us a call at (646) 943-5135 and a friendly team member will help you out. Every takeout order is packed with care, helping to make sure your hamburger or chicken sandwich stays fresh and your fries remain crisp on the journey.

Order Delicious Burgers and Milkshakes at our Restaurant near Murray Hill, Manhattan

At Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer, we’re proud to serve up bold, inspired versions of the classics that people love. From the melt-in-your-mouth beef burgers stacked with cheese to our full lineup of wild and wonderful shakes, we’re taking American cuisine and giving it that signature Black Tap twist. We know that whether you’re a local employee on lunch break, a student grabbing a bite in between classes, a tourist exploring the wonders of the city, or just someone searching for a new favorite spot, the craving for quality burgers and milkshakes is real. We’re here to answer that call.

The next time you’re in the mood for the ultimate hamburger and milkshake experience, skip the ordinary. Choose the place where flavor, creativity, and atmosphere all come together. Black Tap is your go-to burger & shake restaurant near Murray Hill, New York City. Whether you decide to dine at our spot or place an order online for pickup or delivery, we are always happy to serve you. If you have any questions or would like additional information, give us a ring at (646) 943-5135 or contact us online.

Top Burger & Shake Restaurant in New York City near Broadway, Bryant Park, Empire State Building, Fashion District, Flatiron District, Garment District, Gramercy, Grand Central, Grand Central Station, Hell’s Kitchen, Herald Square, Hudson Yards, Kips Bay, Korea Town, Lenox Hill, Macy’s, Madison Square Garden, Midtown, Midtown East, Midtown West, MSG, Murray Hill, Penn Station, Port Authority, Rose Hill, SoHo, Theater District, Times Square, Turtle Bay, Upper East Side, Upper West Side and surrounding areas.